2EZ TEK
Bowflex Max Trainer M9 Loud Thumping Noise in Dallas: A Cracked Internal Housing and the Same Warning Signs as Our Last Warranty Case
← Back to Blog
Case Studies
November 16, 2026
Robby Turner
By Robby Turner, Founder & CEO

Bowflex Max Trainer M9 Loud Thumping Noise in Dallas: A Cracked Internal Housing and the Same Warning Signs as Our Last Warranty Case

A second BowFlex Max Trainer with the same oxidized internal fracture pattern as our last warranty case, same lack of user fault, same years-past-warranty math. Here's what we found and what we're recommending.

Bowflex Max Trainer M9 Loud Thumping Noise in Dallas: A Cracked Internal Housing and the Same Warning Signs as Our Last Warranty Case

We documented a real BowFlex warranty case back in August, a Max Trainer M6 with an internal crankshaft that sheared from metal fatigue, which BowFlex's own support team admitted in writing "may be a material/manufacturing defect" before denying the claim anyway. We said then that we would keep documenting cases like it. Here is the next one.

A note on names: the customer's last name, exact address, and the equipment serial number have been withheld. Everything else is presented as it happened.

Natalie bought her BowFlex Max Trainer M9 in 2021. Five years of normal residential use later, she started hearing a loud thumping noise mid workout. She called 2EZ TEK.

What Our Technician Found

With the cover off, the housing at the right arm's pivot point showed a clear crack, with a visible separation directly adjacent to the mounting hardware. Reddish-brown oxidation was visible at and around the crack line, extending into the interior of the housing, the same signature that made the earlier M6 case credible: a progressive internal fracture that develops gradually under normal use, not a sudden break from an impact or overload. No dents, deformation, or impact marks were present anywhere else on the housing or surrounding frame.

The thumping noise reported is exactly what you would expect as play develops at a joint while an internal crack like this progresses before fully separating.

Why This Looks So Much Like Our Last Case

  • Same brand, same family of machine. Both are BowFlex Max Trainers, one an M6, one an M9.
  • Same failure signature. Both showed oxidation at the fracture line, not a bright, fresh break, meaning both cracks formed gradually over months or years before the part let go.
  • Same lack of user fault. Both units showed normal residential use, no overload, no impact damage, and no way for the owner to have inspected or prevented an internal failure like this.
  • Same warranty math. The M6 case was 4.5 years past its 2 year parts warranty. This M9 is about 5 years past its 3 year frame and parts warranty. Different models, same result: years outside the window by the time a slow internal fatigue crack finally fails.

That pattern matters. One warranty denial on an out of warranty machine is just a warranty working as written. Two separate customers, two different Max Trainer models, both showing the same oxidized, gradually developed internal fracture, is the beginning of a pattern worth a manufacturer actually looking at, not just a parts link and a warranty date.

What We're Recommending

Just like the last case, we are not telling the customer to ignore BowFlex's warranty terms. We are telling her to file the claim with the real technician findings attached, ask directly whether a documented defect finding changes anything, and keep it all in writing. If it gets denied anyway, a Better Business Bureau complaint and a report to the Consumer Product Safety Commission at SaferProducts.gov are both still on the table, since a load bearing part separating mid workout is a safety question independent of the warranty outcome.

2EZ TEK's Position

This is still an ongoing case, and we will update it as it develops, the same way we are still tracking the M6 case. We write these findings down because a technician with the cover off and the part in hand can see things a support queue cannot, and because owners deserve an honest answer before a warranty denial becomes the last word.

If your BowFlex Max Trainer, M6, M9, or otherwise, is making a thumping, knocking, or grinding noise, get it looked at before the part fully separates. 2EZ TEK services BowFlex equipment across Dallas Fort Worth, in home, no drop off required. Call (972) 807-7232 or submit a service request online.

Responses

What are your thoughts?
📄

Looking for your Bowflex manual?

Browse the full Bowflex manual library, owner manuals, assembly guides, and service docs for every model we service.

Browse Bowflex Manuals →

Need fitness equipment service?

2EZ TEK provides repair, assembly, installation, and maintenance across Dallas Fort Worth.

Call (972) 807-7232
Bowflex Max Trainer M9 Loud Thumping Noise in Dallas: A Cracked Internal Housing and the Same Warning Signs as Our Last Warranty Case | 2EZ TEK | 2EZ TEK